Netizens speculate that Seventeen’s album gross sales for ’17 is Proper Right here’ have been manipulated

Netizens speculate that Seventeen’s current album gross sales have been manipulated. Seventeen’s 17 is Proper Right here album has damaged information on the music charts, however some netizens are questioning how the album can promote 5 million copies. The subject grew to become trending on Pann’s neighborhood message board after a netizen shared the gross sales graph under together with a message explaining the rationale behind their doubts.

“With this sort of hype, they need to be No. 1 on the Billboard 200, and so they might tour everywhere in the world in stadiums,” the poster wrote. It’s unimaginable to promote at this degree solely in Asia, and the one international locations the place bodily albums are offered are solely in Korea and Japan, it’s unimaginable to promote 5 million copies with only a bang. In the long run, what drives bodily gross sales is the USA, Europe and different Western markets ought to explode there as properly, however they haven’t any response in Western international locations, so how can Seventeen promote at Taylor Swift’s degree? It’s tough to even uncover Seventeen’s album within the European charts within the UK, France, Germany, and so on. If you happen to have a look at different international locations and even Japan, it is bizarre for a bunch to promote that many copies. Once you look regionally, it is bizarre to have a bunch like Seventeen promote that a lot cash whereas by no means having the hype degree of EXO, BTS or Wanna One. “

Different netizens commented, “I can agree with this. The second the information of the HYBE acquisition got here out, they began leaping to 700k in first week gross sales, however they did not make a single hit. “After that, they saved going up, which was suspicious.” “,” “What you’re saying is offensive, however promoting 5 million for actual is a bit bizarre,” “You sound impolite, however you’re additionally telling the reality,” and extra.

This hypothesis comes on the heels of studies of Seventeen’s ’17 is Proper Right here’ albums being dumped on the streets of Shibuya, Japan.

What are your ideas on this concern?